Saturday, 7 September 2013

Revisting Serving Sizes in ED patients

Do you remember back when we discussed portion distortion (http://anorexiarecovery1.blogspot.ca/2013/03/portion-distortion.html) and talked about how with ED patients, this tends to get a little funky? ED patients have found to have difficulty estimating how much food is on the plate at any given meal. What does this mean? That ED patients somehow see portions as actually being bigger than they really are. This contributes to how difficult recovery can be, as the patient must rely on his/her judgment in order to eat enough. Clearly, this presents a problem if the patient sees that they are eating more food than what is really on the plate. This is why many patients have a treatment team to help them, or measure their food for accuracy.

Let's consider another study that showed the same results: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23276722. This study found that ED patients overestimated how much food was on the plate, and also labelled some meals as being 'large' whereas subjects without ED labelled them as 'small' or 'average/medium'. But WAIT?! What exactly IS a serving size? Not many of us actually measure our our food. This is because we usually have an instinct as to how much is enough for us - in other words, we 'know' how much to eat without meausring. This is not always the case with patients with ED. For the sake of information, let us review what a 'typical' serving size is. One serving of cheese (50g) is about the size of 2 9-volt batteries, while one serving of peanut butter is about the size of a golf ball (30 mL). A piece of meat is about the size of a palm of your habd (75g), and a serving of cooked veggies (125mL) is about the size of an ice-cream scoop or tennis ball. Now, think about your own food. Is this actually the size you eat? Probably not. To be honest, I actually have more than this! But nevertheless, this is what the servings 'look like'. But how many people actually count how many servings of the food groups they eat a day? Not many.

What is the point? Perhaps we are getting too focussed on food group servings that we forget the bigger picture: moderation is essential. If you eat the amount of cheese equal to three batteries instead of two, will you become unhealthy? Likely not. If you have an extra half-cup of vegetables, will you become a superhero? No. It is the LIFESTYLE as a whole that matters. Intake should equal output, and this should be from a variety of foods. This includes desserts as well.

While patients with ED may have a bit of portion distortion, it is not hopeless. I am getting better at realizing how much food I need, although I still have ways to go before I master this. But it is better than a year ago when I first started recovery. My mind is now more open to trying new things as well. In a way, my mind and body have adjusted to my new life without ED, and this is making me a whole lot happier! I still have times when I DO underestimate or even overestimate portions, but that is okay. Recovery is a work in progress. But as I continue, I need to remember one thing: in the long run, portions won't kill me. It is the pattern of over or under eating that will. As long as I eat everything in moderation (meaning, not too much OR too little), I will be healthy. Sure, patients with ED may have trouble getting their serving sizes right. But many other people do. This does not mean that they cannot be healthy. It simply means that maybe they need a little help or direction in realizing how much is enough.

Understanding that 'ENOUGH' means not too much or too little is important. In fact, if you ever come across the correct, medical/scientific definition of malnutrition, it is 'eating more than OR less than what is suitable to meet the demands of one's metabolism and homestasis'. What does this mean? We need to stop worrying so much about the little things that don't matter and start realizing that one's entire lifestyle is more important than a day's meals. For some, this may mean stopping to eat when they are full so that they do not mindlessly graze on food. For others (like some patients with ED), this can mean revisiting their portions and understanding how much food they should be eating. For the rest of us, this can mean eating the way we already eat because we have found a comfortable and healthy balance. To be honest, there is no one powerful almight golden rule of nutrition that states how to have a pefectly healthy life. Except for moderation, laughs, happiness, love, hope, faith, support, knowledge, care, kindness, smiles, perseverance, and good health. A recipe for success.

23 comments:

  1. I read also in another blog that ED victims overestimates their food portion size and body size and underestimates others.
    My question to you when this wrong image be fixed after recovery??

    Kapoor

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good question Kapoor! It is hard to answer - some learn, but some may not. For me, I am always learning. It took me a long time to get to this step, and sometimes I still need help. As long as patients are eating, it is okay!

      Delete
    2. Keep up the good job
      Thanks for answering my question Marina

      Kapoor

      Delete
  2. This was a hard lesson to learn while I was on my treatment.
    The therapist and dietietian spent so much time helping me to know that my meals not as big as I see them and that ED tricks my brain to feel this.
    I am better now and I am taking meals and I still review things with my dietian.
    By the way Marina,I am back to my school and I am very happy seeing my friends but now I am behind one year but my friends are very supportive.
    All my friends were happy to see me healthy.

    Anne

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. WOW Anne! I am so proud of you! I am glad that you are back at school and living your life without ED! AMAZING!

      Delete
    2. Thanks Marina
      All my teachers told me ,if I hadn't gone to treatment,I wouldn't be here today.
      It seems like they were very concerned about me and I was bluffing and shrugging off any advise.
      You motivated me Marina to make my own decision

      Delete
  3. I hope that soon all of us eat our meals and take all the servings of our food without counting or measuring or having a dietetian measure for us.Normal people eat what is enough without measuring.

    S K

    ReplyDelete
  4. I endorse moderation in every thing except kindess,care ,love ,support,faith,smile ,laugh and perseverence.

    Oswaldo

    ReplyDelete
  5. I counsell my clients about modertaions,persevrence and I admire their faith and gave them hopeful messgaes.
    Excellent post Marina ,full of medical facts

    Kelly W

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was advised to stick to Canadian food guide to be healthy.
    I am seeking your opinion Marina.You may remmeber I had depression and I recovered.

    Mays

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mays, of course I remember! The Food Guide is indeed a valuable tool - if it works for you, go for it! Of course, some people do not find it helpful. But for you, I can tell it is working - so keep at it! I am proud of how strong you are!

      Delete
    2. Thank you so much Marina.I am very proud of you as you repressing the excellent picture of a successful middle eastern Canadian young woman

      Mays

      Delete
  7. I never understood what a serving means and how much is a portion size .


    Zak

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Zak - that is my point! Sometimes, as long as you are eating well and enough, it actually does not matter!

      Delete
    2. Make sense
      Thank you Marina

      Zak

      Delete
  8. Very helpful info especilly for those recovering.
    I agree that most people even those who recovered still overestimate their portion and the amount they eat and still feel full stomach even if they had little meal.Not surprizing also feel fat when they are very thin.
    Good new I am for one completely recovered and all negative thoughts of ED gove with the winds for ever.

    Recoeverd ED victim

    ReplyDelete
  9. I always make sure I eat my meals and snacks on time .I do not have ED but I like to be healthy.I use Canadian food guide as my guide for portions and servings.
    When I do not feel hungry as when I am under stress,I eat same as you by hour and use Canadain guide for what a healthy meal and sncak contains
    It works for me and protects me for fatigue

    This is what I coomeneted on your previous post.
    I want you to post my same comment again if you do not mind

    Sorina

    ReplyDelete
  10. I love the picture
    That is exactly my meal.vegy,protein,carb,fruits,salds and a drink (could be milk)

    Yara

    ReplyDelete
  11. I love the picture and I will make my dish same like this from now on

    Thanks

    Ivanka

    ReplyDelete
  12. I learnt too much from this post.
    Thannks


    Sasha

    ReplyDelete
  13. As you may recall being recovered from alcohol and depression ,I needed to make sure eating well.I will use tips from this blog and eat all the recommeded serving 5 meals daily

    Carlos

    ReplyDelete
  14. I learnt a lot from this post.

    Hend

    ReplyDelete
  15. Your wrighting always impressing and intriguing,
    full of well searched and up to date info.

    Hamza

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.